Mainstream NFT Success: Case Studies from Reddit and NBA Top Shots

People have always paid large sums to stand out. Designer clothing, a $115 billion market, reflects this desire. NFTs tap into this same need, allowing individuals to build their digital identity with unique digital items.

NFTs have actually proven their success with platforms like Reddit and NBA Top Shots. By using familiar web2 interfaces and avoiding crypto jargon, they’ve set the stage for NFTs to become everyday tools—reward systems, tickets, digital collectibles, and profile pictures—all seamlessly integrated into our digital lives.

So how can a web2 brand launch a successful NFT project? Let’s examine what Reddit did right.

Reddit’s NFT success wasn’t due to utility but clever marketing. Branded as collectibles and avoiding the term “NFT,” they used familiar web2 language. “Crypto wallet” became “Reddit Vault,” and purchases were in fiat currency. This simplicity and approachability made Reddit’s NFTs popular, proving accessibility is key.

Before we break down each aspect that Reddit and NBA Top Shots got right, feel free to watch our engaging explanation on YouTube

It’s important to note that the size of these brands is not the reason for their success. Large, well-capitalized brands like Porsche and Game of Thrones have launched NFT projects that have become epic failures. On the other hand, Reddit launched an NFT collection that now boasts over 4.25 million unique wallets, with some avatar selections gaining a floor price of $3.7K.

Reddit’s success can be attributed to several key factors. First and foremost, they focused on simplicity and accessibility. Unlike many NFT projects that get bogged down in technical jargon and complicated processes, Reddit used familiar web2 terminology. The benefits of blockchain were delivered without requiring any technical knowledge or understanding of the technology.

Additionally, Reddit avoided the exclusive use of cryptocurrencies for transactions. Users could purchase avatars using fiat currency, removing a significant barrier to entry for those unfamiliar with or skeptical of cryptocurrencies. This inclusive approach widened their potential audience, making it easier for everyday users to participate.

Furthermore, Reddit integrated these collectibles into their existing platform seamlessly. The NFTs served as profile pictures and added a glow effect on user comments, offering a tangible benefit within the Reddit ecosystem. This integration made the NFTs relevant and desirable for active Reddit users, fostering a sense of community and engagement.

Lastly, the marketing strategy was pivotal. By not using the term “NFT” and avoiding crypto jargon, Reddit demystified the concept for its user base. They positioned the avatars as exclusive and unique, tapping into the collectible mindset. This strategic branding, combined with the ease of use and integration into the Reddit platform, drove the success of their NFT collection.

The Marketing Magic Behind NFT Success!

Many high-utility NFT projects have struggled to maintain success. These are the projects that promise extensive functionalities and benefits, but frequently fail to attract and retain a large user base. Understanding the reasons behind these failures can provide valuable insights into the NFT market dynamics.

High utility NFT projects have failed because they overcomplicate the user experience, rely too heavily on crypto knowledge, and face challenges in maintaining supply-demand balance. Simplifying access and clear value propositions are crucial for success.

The utility of owning a Reddit NFT is minimal compared to other projects that ultimately were less successful. Reddit NFTs primarily focused on digital identity, a fundamental aspect of all NFTs, and provided limited utility, such as glowing comments. The true success was from the marketing.

Brands like Porsche and Game of Thrones may have failed because they didn’t tailor their approach to their audience’s needs and expectations; overcomplicating the user experience combined with providing no clear value leads to disengagement and failure. 

Reddit’s strategy of simplicity, accessibility, and relevance sets a benchmark for how NFTs can be successfully integrated into mainstream platforms.

Higher utility NFT projects typically offer features like gaming capabilities, decentralized finance (DeFi) integrations, and complex ownership structures. While these features can be appealing, they often come with a steep learning curve. Users unfamiliar with blockchain technology can find these projects daunting, leading to lower adoption rates.

Additionally, many high-utility NFT projects require users to interact with multiple platforms and wallets, adding layers of complexity. This can deter potential users who are not tech-savvy or who are hesitant to invest time in learning new systems. Simplified user experiences, like those provided by NBA Top Shots and Reddit, are essential for broader adoption.

Moreover, these projects often struggle with maintaining a balance between supply and demand. Overproduction of NFTs can lead to market saturation, reducing the perceived value of each token. This was a significant issue for projects like Axie Infinity and even NBA Top Shots at a later stage. Successful NFT projects need to manage their supply carefully to maintain demand and value.

Now, let’s shed more light on another company that has been monumental in showing web2 brands the power NFTs have.

NBA Top Shots: A Case Study in Simplification

Another immensely successful NFT project that used similar marketing tactics was NBA Top Shots. Marketed as a virtual trading card platform, it had partnerships with the NBA and the NBA Players Association. 

NBA Top Shots’ success stemmed from its user-friendly approach, allowing purchases with traditional payment methods and avoiding the need for cryptocurrency knowledge. This accessibility and familiar payment options drove widespread adoption and high sales volumes.

The project was so successful that in February 2021, it generated $224 million in sales volume in that month alone. Unfortunately, about a year later, Top Shots saw a significant decline for the same reason Axie Infinity did; the market was flooded with supply, causing demand to drop significantly. Watch our explanation on why Axie Infinity failed here.

NBA Top Shots showcased the potential of integrating NFTs with mainstream brands and entertainment sectors. Moreover, NBA Top Shots’ ability to generate excitement and community engagement around the release of new packs and Moments highlighted the importance of creating a dynamic and interactive user experience. 

Regular drops and the anticipation of acquiring rare Moments kept users engaged and invested in the platform, demonstrating the power of community-driven participation in the success of NFT projects.

The Future of NFTs: Ubiquity and Integration

It’s becoming clear that the ability to verify ownership of digital goods is a multibillion-dollar market. However, the term “NFTs” has garnered a negative connotation, and people dislike the “complicated” hurdles associated with setting up a blockchain-based wallet. 

Despite this, web2 brands are mastering the art of simplifying these hurdles, as demonstrated by Reddit and NBA Top Shots. Soon, NFTs will be ubiquitous, seamlessly integrated into our digital lives without the average consumer even realizing it—much like how most people don’t realize that AI powers Face ID when they unlock their iPhones.

The future of NFTs lies in their seamless integration into everyday digital experiences, simplifying the process and removing the stigma of complex crypto terminology. This approach will make NFTs more accessible and widely accepted.

The negative connotations associated with NFTs can be mitigated by focusing on usability and relevance. By making NFTs an invisible yet integral part of our digital interactions, much like AI in smartphones, they can become a ubiquitous feature of the online world.

This shift will allow NFTs to fulfill their potential as tools for verifying ownership, creating digital identities, and enhancing online experiences without the average user needing to understand the underlying technology. Just as AI has seamlessly integrated into various aspects of our lives, making processes smoother and more efficient, NFTs can do the same for digital ownership and identity verification.

Web2 brands have a unique advantage in this space. They can leverage their existing user bases and familiarity to introduce NFTs in a way that feels natural and intuitive. This strategy not only promotes wider adoption but also helps in demystifying NFTs, making them a part of the everyday digital experience.

The future of NFTs is bright, with the potential to become as commonplace and essential as the technologies we use daily.

I hope you found this article informative and continue to stay informed with NFT Explained. You can also find us on YouTube!

If you wish to support our educational mission and protect your digital assets, please consider collaborating with our partners by purchasing a Ledger hardware wallet!


As a passionate enthusiast of blockchain technology and its intersection with finance, I eagerly ventured into the captivating realm of cryptocurrencies in 2019. Fueled by my curiosity for the financial landscape shaped by this innovative technology, I find great satisfaction in creating content about this ever progressing terrain. For more information about me and NFT explained, click on the "About Us" page.

Recent Posts